Post updated for 2025

When it comes to makeup essentials, a good liquid eyeliner can make all the difference. As a makeup enthusiast who has tried numerous drugstore options, I understand the importance of finding the perfect tool without breaking the bank. In this article, I’ll be sharing my top picks for the best drugstore liquid eyeliners based on personal testing and audience feedback.

I recently conducted a survey on Instagram and YouTube to gather insights on the best drugstore liquid liners, and after rigorous testing, I’ve compiled a list of the top four contenders. Join me as I delve into their application, finish, performance on oily lids, and waterproof capabilities.

Watch the video above for detailed wear tests, or continue reading for the final rankings.

#4: wet n wild Breakup Proof Skinny Eyeliner

Buy on Walmart, Ulta Beauty

The wet n wild Breakup Proof Skinny Liquid Eyeliner, though ranked fourth, offers some impressive features. Its ultra-fine brush tip allows for precise winged looks, although it may require practice due to its thin lines. Priced at around $6, it’s a budget-friendly option.

You can achieve a sleek winged look with this liner, but be aware of its potential for cracking after extended wear. While not completely waterproof, it offers decent longevity and affordability.

#3: Maybelline Tattoo Studio Ink Pen Eyeliner

Buy on Ulta Beauty, Amazon

The Maybelline Tattoo Studio Ink Pen Eyeliner delivers an intense matte black finish, perfect for bold looks. Its tapered brush tip allows for versatile application, from fine lines to bold strokes.