Organic makeup products are gaining popularity as a cleaner and eco-friendly option for cosmetic lovers. Among these products, a staple item in many makeup bags is eyeliner. Eyeliner helps define and accentuate the eyes, and using organic eyeliner provides a natural alternative to traditional eyeliners, which may contain harmful chemicals and additives.
The best organic eyeliners are made from natural, non-toxic ingredients that are gentle on the skin and less likely to cause irritation. They should also be eco-friendly and ethically sourced, responsible for both your skin and the environment. Organic eyeliner has come a long way, now offering the same long-lasting, pigmented results as their non-organic counterparts.
When looking to purchase an organic eyeliner, it is crucial to consider factors such as the type of applicator, staying power, and pigmentation. Additionally, it is essential to ensure that the product is genuinely organic and carries a certified organic seal. Lastly, take into account any personal preferences, such as the preferred finish (matte or shimmer) and how easily the product can be removed.
Having considered the benefits of organic eyeliners and the critical factors to take into account when purchasing one, let us now delve into our top picks for the best organic eyeliners that meet these criteria and enhance your makeup routine.
The 7 Best Organic Eyeliners:
We have carefully curated a list of the top organic eyeliners for you to choose from, ensuring that your makeup routine remains both eco-friendly and high-quality.
1. Au Naturale Organic Eye Liner Pencil in Deep Sea
We think this Au Naturale Organic Eye Liner Pencil is a brilliant choice for those looking for an organic, cruelty-free eyeliner with nourishing and long-lasting properties.
Pros
- Infused with Castor Oil for lash growth
- Vibrant, long-lasting color
- Vegan, cruelty-free, and gluten-free formula
Cons
- Sharpening the pencil could be tricky
- Some users reported a smudging issue
- High price point for some users
The Au Naturale Organic Eye Liner Pencil has truly impressed us with its unique combination of both elegance and nourishment. The Castor Oil-infusion not only enhances your look but also encourages lash growth, making it an excellent addition to your makeup routine.
Furthermore, this eyeliner’s waterproof, vegan, cruelty-free, and gluten-free formula ensures ethical sourcing and remarkable wear. It’s a pleasure to apply, boasting a variety of vibrant colors that remain consistent throughout the day. We appreciate that Au Naturale not only focuses on style but also takes good care of our skin with their consciously crafted product.
However, it’s important to note a few potential drawbacks. Some customers have reported issues with sharpening the pencil, leading to a less precise application. Others have mentioned a smudging problem, which may affect your overall look. Lastly, the price point is relatively high – something to consider when opting for this organic eyeliner.
In conclusion, the Au Naturale Organic Eye Liner Pencil is an amazing product for those seeking a stylish and nourishing eyeliner option. Its high-quality ingredients and ethical sourcing make it worth considering, despite some minor issues that can be managed with some practice and care.
2. Honeybee Gardens Effortless Black Matte Eye Liner Pencil
If you’re seeking a smooth, long-wearing eyeliner for sensitive eyes, our Honeybee Gardens Effortless Black Matte Eye Liner Pencil is a top choice.
Pros
- Highly pigmented matte black color
- Smooth application for easy use
- Gluten-free, vegan, and paraben-free
Cons
- Not waterproof or smudge-proof
- May not be suitable for waterline application
- Lighter in color than some traditional eyeliners
We recently tried out the Honeybee Gardens Eye Liner Pencil and were impressed with its performance. The highly pigmented matte black color (Jet Set) glided on effortlessly due to its smooth application, allowing for precise lines. As a bonus, this eyeliner is gluten-free, vegan, and paraben-free, making it an excellent option for those with sensitivities or allergies.
On the flip side, we found that this eyeliner is not entirely waterproof or smudge-proof. While it does fairly well against sweating and tearing, it may not hold up against more intense conditions. We also noticed that it isn’t ideal for use on the waterline, as the color is lighter than some traditional eyeliners, and may not last as long.
However, for those with sensitive eyes, the Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner Pencil is a great option due to its gentle and non-irritating formula. Additionally, it’s easy to remove at the end of the day – a perk for those who struggle with eye irritation from stubborn makeup. The beauty experts at BeautyMag have even named it one of their top beauty picks for 2021, both for sensitive eyes and organic eyeliners.
In conclusion, we highly recommend the Honeybee Gardens Effortless Black Matte Eye Liner Pencil for those seeking an organic and gentle option, especially if you have sensitive eyes. With its smooth application and deep pigmentation, it’s sure to become a staple in your makeup routine.
3. Physicians Formula Organic Wear Eyeliner
We believe that this organic eyeliner is a great choice for those looking for a high-quality and gentle option with soothing ingredients.
Pros
- Highly pigmented and smudge-resistant
- Infused with soothing organic ingredients
- Fine brush tip for smooth and easy application
Cons
- May require practice for thin lines
- Needs some time to dry
- Consistency may be thick for some users
Physicians Formula Organic Wear Eyeliner is a game-changer for those who prefer organic makeup products. Infused with a nourishing blend of organic chamomile oil, aloe vera, and jojoba oil, this liquid eyeliner feels gentle on the skin, making it suitable for those with sensitivities. Its botanical cactus flower also adds a unique element to the formula, providing additional soothing properties.
The fine brush tip applicator is designed for a smooth and easy application, allowing you to create precise lines that last all day. The highly pigmented and smudge-resistant formula ensures that your eyeliner looks fresh and clean throughout the day. However, it may require some practice for those who are new to liquid eyeliner, especially when aiming for thin lines. Additionally, be patient and allow some time for it to dry to avoid smudging.
The only downside we noticed is that the consistency might be too thick for some users, making the application slightly challenging. Nonetheless, adding a few drops of water can smooth out the formula if needed.
In conclusion, the Physicians Formula Organic Wear Eyeliner is an excellent choice for those looking for an organic and gentle eyeliner option. While it may require some practice and patience, it is worth the investment, considering its high pigmentation, smudge-resistance, and soothing organic ingredients.
4. Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner
This liquid eyeliner is a fantastic choice for anyone seeking a high-quality, lasting product with natural ingredients.
Pros
- Flexible felt brush tip for precise application
- Plant-derived ingredients gentle on sensitive eyes
- Bold color and satin finish that lasts up to 8 hours
Cons
- May take some practice for perfect application
- Some users reported irritation after several uses
- Wand size may not be ideal for some users
We recently tried the Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner, and we were really impressed by its high-quality and natural ingredients. The flexible felt brush tip applicator makes it easy to create precise lines and wings that last throughout the day. Plus, the plant-derived ingredients are gentle enough for sensitive eyes, yet still provide highly pigmented, bold color.
One of the standout features of this eyeliner is its satin finish that stays in place for up to 8 hours without flaking, budging, or smudging. It’s perfect for anyone with an active lifestyle or busy schedule, as it requires minimal touch-ups throughout the day.
However, there are a few potential drawbacks to consider before purchasing this product. Some users found that it took a bit of practice to achieve perfect application, and others reported irritation after using the eyeliner multiple times. Additionally, the wand size may not be ideal for everyone, with some users opting to use their own applicator for a finer line.
Overall, we highly recommend the Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner for anyone in search of a reliable and natural option that provides excellent color payoff and long-lasting wear. Just be prepared to spend some time learning how to apply it perfectly for the best results.
5. Mom’s Secret 100% Natural Liquid Eyeliner
We believe the Mom’s Secret 100% Natural Liquid Eyeliner is a suitable choice for those seeking a natural and organic option for their eye makeup.
Pros
- Easy to apply with felt tip pen
- Gentle formula with no harsh chemicals or artificial fragrances
- Long-lasting and smudge-proof wear
Cons
- Inconsistent texture and consistency
- Not as much product as expected
- Additional herbs not mentioned in the description
The Mom’s Secret 100% Natural Liquid Eyeliner is a great alternative to conventional eyeliners, as it is made from all-natural ingredients. It contains 75% organic content and is vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free. Moreover, it is manufactured in the USA. This eyeliner is a perfect choice for those who prefer gentle and eco-friendly makeup.
We appreciate that the felt tip pen design makes the application process smooth and precise, allowing beginners and professionals alike to create the desired look. Additionally, the formula is gentle on the eyes, which is essential for those with sensitive skin. It’s also smudge-proof, ensuring that your makeup lasts all day long.
However, there are a few drawbacks to this product. Some users have reported inconsistent texture and consistency, making the application challenging. Also, the container holds less product than expected, which could be a downside for frequent users. Additionally, there are extra herbs listed on the bottle that weren’t mentioned in the description, potentially causing concern for those with specific allergies or preferences.
In conclusion, although the Mom’s Secret 100% Natural Liquid Eyeliner has some minor issues, overall, it remains a solid option for anyone looking to incorporate a natural and organic eyeliner into their daily beauty routine.
6. BaeBlu Organic Gel Eyeliner
We recommend the BaeBlu Organic Gel Eyeliner Pot for those who prefer a natural, versatile, and smudge-proof eyeliner experience.
Pros
- Great for sensitive eyes
- Blendable and smudgeable, but stays put once dry
- Made with certified organic and all-natural ingredients
Cons
- Not the easiest to apply
- Can dry out over time
- Weak pigmentation for some users
We recently tried the BaeBlu Organic Gel Eyeliner Pot, and we were mostly pleased with its performance. The all-natural ingredients make it an excellent option for those with sensitive eyes or who are looking for cruelty-free makeup. This formula is very blendable and smudgeable, allowing for various looks ranging from a classic thin line to a dramatic smoky eye. However, once it’s dry, it won’t budge – ensuring your makeup stays flawless throughout the day.
The creamy gel texture makes for an interesting application experience. Though we didn’t have too much trouble applying the product, some users found it a bit difficult to get a consistent and smooth line. So, if you’re new to using gel eyeliners or have shaky hands, you may need some practice to get the perfect line.
The only major downside we noticed was that the eyeliner can dry out over time, necessitating the addition of a few drops of oil (such as rosehip oil) to revive its consistency. Despite this, the BaeBlu eyeliner is still a solid option for those looking to choose a more natural and organic product.
In summary, the BaeBlu Organic Gel Eyeliner Pot is a great choice for anyone seeking an all-natural and versatile eyeliner that works well for sensitive eyes. Although its application may require some practice and the product can dry out over time, its benefits make it worth a try.
7. BaeBlu Organic Liquid Eyeliner
For those looking for an organic eyeliner, BaeBlu offers a decent option, but may not be perfect for all users.
Pros
- Gentle on sensitive eyes with all-natural ingredients
- Water-proof, smudge-proof, and sweat-proof for 24-hour wear
- Quick-drying formula for maximum color without chemicals
Cons
- Applicator tip may be awkward to use for some
- Inconsistent product quality reported by customers
- Possible difficulty in achieving a fine point
We were excited to try the BaeBlu Organic Liquid Eyeliner, as it boasts a gentle formula that’s ideal for sensitive eyes. After applying it, we found the 24-hour staying power to be impressive. It held up throughout the day without smudging or wearing off. The quick-drying formula and maximum color without chemicals make it a healthier choice for eye makeup.
However, not everything was perfect with this product. The tapered felt tip applicator seemed awkward to use, especially when trying to achieve a fine point. We understand that some users had difficulty with this aspect of the eyeliner. Additionally, some customers reported inconsistent product quality, which made us wonder if there may be occasional issues with manufacturing.
Overall, the BaeBlu Organic Liquid Eyeliner is a decent choice for those seeking an organic and gentle product that can stay put all day. However, due to the potential issues with the applicator and quality consistency, it may not be the best choice for everyone.
Buying Guide
When it comes to choosing the best organic eyeliner, there are several factors to consider. We’ve compiled a list of essential features to look for in a product while shopping. This buying guide will help you make an informed decision and select the perfect organic eyeliner that suits your needs.
Ingredient Quality
The first consideration should always be the quality of ingredients used in the eyeliner. Look for products that contain natural and organic ingredients. Make sure to read the label thoroughly and be cautious of synthetic chemicals or dyes that could be harmful to your skin.
Staying Power
A good organic eyeliner should have the ability to last throughout the day without smudging or fading. This is especially important if you have oily skin or plan to wear your makeup in humid environments. To test the staying power of an eyeliner, gently rub your finger over the swatch and see if it withstands the friction.
Ease of Application
The eyeliner should be easy to apply, providing a smooth and precise line. Many organic eyeliners come in various forms, such as pencils, liquids, and gels. Consider which type suits your preferences and skill level.
Pencils are great for beginners, as they offer better control and are easier to smudge for a more smoky look. On the other hand, liquid eyeliners deliver sharp and precise lines, perfect for creating winged tips. Gel eyeliners usually come in a pot and require a brush for application, ideal for those with a steady hand and more experience.
Color Options
While black is the most common eyeliner color, exploring different shades can inspire a variety of makeup looks. When shopping for an organic eyeliner, check if the brand offers a diverse color range, including vibrant hues and more subdued shades.
Budget
Finally, consider your budget when shopping for organic eyeliner. While many high-quality options come at a higher price point, it’s still possible to find affordable products that don’t compromise on quality.
By considering these features and factors, you can make an informed decision and find the perfect organic eyeliner to complete your makeup bag.
Frequently Asked Questions
What ingredients should one look for in a healthy and safe eyeliner?
When searching for a healthy and safe eyeliner, look for ingredients derived from natural sources. Some examples include plant-based oils, such as jojoba oil, avocado oil, and coconut oil. Also, consider eyeliners with natural pigments like fruit and vegetable extracts. Avoid products containing synthetic ingredients, such as parabens, phthalates, and sulfates, as well as artificial dyes and fragrances.
Which organic eyeliner brands are recommended for sensitive eyes?
Several organic eyeliner brands cater to sensitive eyes, including 100% Pure, Alima Pure, and Juice Beauty. These brands generally use gentle, plant-based ingredients and avoid harsh chemicals, synthetic fragrances, and artificial dyes. Additionally, they often utilize hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic formulations, making them suitable for those with sensitive eyes.
How does one choose the best natural eyeliner for use on the waterline?
The waterline is a delicate area, requiring a gentle eyeliner with staying power. Consider choosing a natural eyeliner that is specifically designed for use on the waterline, such as ophthalmologist-tested or water-resistant formulations. Also, opt for eyeliners with nourishing ingredients, like aloe vera or chamomile, to soothe the sensitive waterline area.
Are there any drugstore organic eyeliners that offer professional quality?
Yes, several drugstore organic eyeliners offer professional quality at an affordable price. Brands like Burt’s Bees, Physicians Formula, and Pacifica provide natural and cruelty-free options. These products often contain nourishing ingredients, such as vitamin E and natural oils, and offer excellent pigment and staying power.
What are the benefits of using a chemical-free eyeliner pencil?
Using a chemical-free eyeliner pencil has various benefits. It reduces the risk of irritation, inflammation, and allergic reactions often caused by synthetic ingredients found in traditional eyeliners. Additionally, natural ingredients provide nourishment and hydration, promoting healthier skin and lashes. Finally, chemical-free eye pencils are often cruelty-free and environmentally friendly, appealing to those concerned about animal welfare and the planet.
What options are available for non-toxic eyeliner pencils for aging eyes?
Many non-toxic eyeliner pencils are suitable for aging eyes, as they contain nourishing and hydrating ingredients that help boost the appearance of the delicate eye area. Look for pencils rich in antioxidants, such as vitamin C and E, to help combat signs of aging. Additionally, choose options with gentle, plant-based ingredients that are less likely to cause irritation or inflammation, which can exacerbate wrinkles and fine lines.
This article was last updated on December 3, 2023 .
